All 50 state notices remain on publication hold.
This is independent public-interest research, not legal advice, an official agency form, attorney-reviewed material or certified legal guidance. A notice does not initiate an appeal, pause a deadline, prevent an investigation or override court authority. Follow the actual notice, verify the current rule and case posture, and preserve proof of receipt and filing.
West Virginia — 60-day grievance to contest a substantiation when there is no judicial finding
Statutory framework
- W. Va. Code §49-4-601b applies where the Department substantiates abuse or neglect against a person but there is no resulting judicial finding. The Department must provide written notice by certified mail, return receipt requested.
- The person has a statutory right to contest the substantiation by filing a grievance with the Department's Board of Review, and a right to appeal an adverse Board decision to court under the Administrative Procedures Act.
- The June 2025 West Virginia Child Protective Services Policy, §8.2, says the maltreater must complete the Board of Review hearing request form and return it to the worker's supervisor or send it to the Board of Review within 60 days after receipt of the substantiation notice. The policy also says the person may request their file at no charge, excluding reporter-identifying information.
- The policy describes a supervisor review step. If the supervisor determines the substantiation is appropriate, the supervisor completes the agency section and sends the request to the Board within 30 days of receipt. The Board hearing is governed by W. Va. Code §29A-5-1 et seq. and 69 CSR 1.
- The statute has separate record-sealing consequences: if a petition could have been filed but was not, Department records generally must be sealed one year after substantiation unless another allegation is substantiated during that year. If a petition is filed and does not result in an adjudication that abuse or neglect occurred, the allegation is treated as unsubstantiated. Where a judicial finding is made, a person may petition the court to seal the Department record after at least five years, subject to statutory conditions.
Critical limits
This grievance route is specifically for the statutory situation with no resulting judicial finding. It should not be presented as a way to relitigate an existing abuse/neglect adjudication. The 60-day trigger in the June 2025 policy is receipt of the notice; preserve the certified-mail envelope, return receipt and any proof of actual delivery. The statute and policy are not identical in every detail, so the actual notice and current Board form must be checked.
W. Va. Code §49-4-601b · West Virginia CPS Policy, revised June 2025, §8.2 · W. Va. Code §49-2-105 (general review provision; do not substitute for §49-4-601b)
Virginia — three-level appeal of a founded disposition
What the current rules and VDSS guidance establish
- Virginia defines a founded disposition by a preponderance-of-the-evidence standard. A founded disposition can result in a confidential Central Registry entry; registry retention varies with the severity level and applicable law.
- Under 22VAC40-705-190 and Code §63.2-1526, the person may submit a written request to amend the founded determination and related records within 30 days after being notified. The first stage is an informal local conference. The local department must notify the child abuse and neglect information system that an appeal is pending.
- The second stage is a state administrative appeal hearing. VDSS guidance says a request may be made if the local department does not respond to the local-conference request within 45 calendar days, or if the person disagrees with the local conference outcome. The state-hearing request must be made within 30 calendar days after receiving the local conference outcome.
- The third stage is judicial review. VDSS's current public appeal page states that the appellant must file a written notice of appeal with the Commissioner within 30 days of receiving the hearing officer's decision (or the date it was mailed, whichever is earlier), then file a petition in circuit court within 30 days after filing that notice. Follow the decision letter and current statute for the exact procedural requirements.
- If a criminal charge or investigation is filed or commenced against the appellant for the same conduct involving the same child, the appeal is stayed until the trial-court prosecution is completed, the criminal investigation is closed, or 180 days have passed since the appeal request, as specified by statute and rule.
Audit action / remaining hold
Do not compress Virginia's three stages into one 30-day deadline. The first 30 days run from notification of the founded determination; the next 30 days run from receipt of the local conference outcome; judicial review has its own two-step filing sequence. The 45-day local response period is a trigger for access to the state stage, not the initial appeal deadline.
22VAC40-705-190 — Appeals · Virginia DSS — CPS Rights of Appeal · Virginia DSS — CPS Appeals
North Carolina — assessment findings and juvenile-court proceedings are distinct
What the statutes and court guidance establish
- North Carolina's CPS framework under G.S. Chapter 7B requires an assessment using a family assessment or investigative assessment response. An abuse report must be initiated immediately and no later than 24 hours after receipt; neglect or dependency reports must be initiated within 72 hours. The Judicial Branch describes completion of the assessment within 45 days.
- North Carolina uses the terms substantiated and unsubstantiated in describing CPS assessment results. A substantiated CPS assessment is not itself a juvenile-court adjudication. Court jurisdiction and adjudication arise through a petition and judicial process.
- G.S. 7B-302(h) sets conditions for entry into a private residence for assessment purposes: reasonable belief of imminent danger of death or serious physical injury, permission of the parent/person responsible, accompaniment by an officer with legal authority to enter, or a court order.
- G.S. 7B-302(f) and (g) provide five-working-day notices and five-working-day review rights to the person who made the report in specified situations, including review of a decision not to accept a report or not to file a petition. Those reporter review rights are not an appeal right belonging to the parent or alleged perpetrator challenging a substantiated assessment.
- When a juvenile court enters an order in an abuse, neglect or dependency case, appeal rights attach to qualifying court orders and parties under Chapter 7B and appellate rules. That is a judicial appeal, not an administrative appeal of a county CPS assessment finding.
- Effective April 1, 2026, amendments to G.S. 7B-302 and related provisions changed petition-signing and legal-review language. Older manuals and summaries may not reflect the current text.
Audit action / remaining hold
This pass did not identify a general statewide administrative appeal process for a parent to overturn a county CPS substantiation finding comparable to West Virginia or Virginia. Do not invent a 30-day or 60-day parent appeal deadline. Identify whether the challenged action is a county assessment result, a court petition/order, a service decision or a separate record-access matter, then use the correct statute and forum. The current CPS Administrative Policies Manual is dated September 30, 2025; verify any later county or statewide policy changes before relying on it.
North Carolina General Statutes — Chapter 7B · North Carolina Judicial Branch — Abuse, Neglect and Dependency · NC DHHS CPS Administrative Policies Manual (Sept. 30, 2025)
Cross-state findings
- West Virginia: 60 days from receipt under the June 2025 policy for the statutory Board of Review grievance when no judicial finding resulted.
- Virginia: three appeal levels with separate 30-day windows and a 45-day local-response trigger; pending related criminal matters can stay the process.
- North Carolina: no general parent administrative appeal deadline was established in this pass; the five-day review rights found in §7B-302 belong to the reporting person in specified circumstances.
- Common distinction: an agency assessment, a substantiation/founded disposition, a Central Registry entry and a juvenile-court adjudication are separate legal events.
Scope and release decision
This pass focused on substantiation/founded findings and available review routes. It did not complete a full audit of interviews, home entry beyond the cited North Carolina statute, emergency removal, complete records access, or all retention and expungement rules. The state notice PDFs were not edited.
Release decision: HOLD. No state is cleared by this pass. All 50 state notices remain research drafts. No attorney review, legal certification or case-specific legal suitability is claimed.
← Pass 26 audit · Pass 25 audit · Project homepage